Leg Pain Practice Scenario
Author – Ansaam El-Sherif Editor – James Mackintosh
Last updated 24/01/24
Table of Contents
How to Use
Candidate:
- Read the brief below (1 minute).
- Take a history (6 minutes).
- Answer viva questions (3 minutes).
Patient/Examiner:
- Familiarise yourself with the history & examination findings
- After completing the history, viva the candidate
Candidate Brief
John is a 60 year old man presenting to his GP with leg pain. Please take a history, carry out a focussed examination and answer the questions that follow.
- History
- Examination
- Viva
History of Presenting Complaint
- Site – pain is present bilaterally in the lower legs
- Onset – started around 6-7 months ago
- Character – cramping
- Radiation – none (if asked specifically no shooting pains down the back of the leg)
- Associated symptoms – none. (if asked specifically no back pain)
- Timing – worse when walking. Candidate should explore this further, the patient was initially able to walk for around one hour, but now has to stop every 10 minutes.
- Exacerbating/ Relieving factors – rest makes the pain better. Pain is worse when walking.
- Severity – 6/10
ICE
- Ideas – could this be some sort of muscular pain, or just a part of ‘getting old’
- Concerns – isn’t particularly concerned about the pain, but wants it to be treated
- Expectations – wants some pain-relief so he can walk as well as he used too!
Systems review
- Red flags: no fever, no weight loss, no night sweats
- Cardiovascular: no palpitations, no syncope, no chest pain.
- Respiratory: no shortness of breath, no cough
Past Medical History
- Diabetes – type 2 diabetes, diagnosed 5 years ago
- Hypertension
- If candidate attempts to ask about diabetic or hypertension control, the actor should appear irritated and defensive. If the candidate enquires in a sensitive manner, the patient admits that they aren’t very compliant with their medication, as they feel fine and don’t see the point. Give candidates an opportunity to counsel regarding the importance of diabetic and hypertensive control, and if the candidate is empathetic and understanding agree to think about this further.
Medications
- Metformin
- Lorsartan
- Simvastatin
Allergies
- Ramipril – if candidates ask specifically about the nature of the allergy, the patient explains he had a dry cough
Family History
- Father had a heart attack at the age of 65, older brother has angina
Social History
- Works as an account
- Lives at home with his wife, has 2 children and 3 grandchildren
- Smokes 10 cigarettes a day for the last 10 years
- Basic observations: temperature 37.2, heart rate 60, oxygen saturations 97%, blood pressure 155/98, respiratory rate 14
- General Inspection – comfortable at rest
- Hands – normal CRT, no clubbing, evidence of tar staining
- Face – no conjunctival pallor, no cyanosis
- Vascular examination
- Radial pulses equal
- Normal JVP
- Temperature of feet and lower legs is cold
- Dorsalis pedis, tibialis posterior and the popliteal pulses cannot be palpated
- No evidence of skin changes or ulcers in the legs
- No evidence of peripheral oedema
- Examination of the chest
- Inspection – no scars
- No heaves or thrills
- Heart sounds I + II present, with no added sounds
1. What are your key differential diagnoses?
- Peripheral vascular disease: The patient gives a typical history of intermittent claudication, with cramping pain on exertion that is better with rest. In addition, the patient has multiple cardiac risk factors, such as hypertension, diabetes, and smoking (1).
- The lack of radiation or classical ‘shooting pains’ suggest that nerve compression is less likely, however this is still an important differential to consider.
- Arthritis: This is unlikely based on the history described above.
2.Please discuss your management plan with the patient.
- Intermittent claudication should be explained to the patient.
- The patient should be counselled about optimising diabetes and hypertension control.
- Antiplatelet therapy (clopidogrel) should be discussed, with explanation about the importance of preventing future cardiovascular events (2).
- Signposting to services to support in smoking cessation.
- The importance of lifestyle interventions (diet, exercise) should also be discussed, with discussion about the importance of statins for lowering risk even if there are few symptoms.
- Supervised exercise programme
- The patient should ask about surgery, as his neighbour had “some sort of procedure to improve the blood supply to his legs”. Candidate should explain that this would only be offered if the supervised exercise programme and lifestyle interventions are unsuccessful
- Refer to NICE guidelines (3) and CKS (1) for more detailed guidelines.
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Peripheral Arterial disease [Internet]. NICE; 2022 [revised 2022 Jul; cited 2023 March 23]. Available from: https://cks.nice.org.uk/topics/peripheral-arterial-disease/
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Clopidogrel and modified-release dipyramidole for the prevention of occlusive vascular events [Internet]. NICE; 2010 [published 2010 Dec 15; cited 2023 March 23]. (Technology Appraisal Guidance TA210). Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta210
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Peripheral arterial disease: diagnosis and management [Internet]. NICE; 2012; [updated 2020 Dec 11; cited 2023 March 23]. (Clinical Guidelines [CG147]). Available from: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg147